Becoming Townsend

Becoming Townsend
Like the pottery at Yorkshire...

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Underlings: The Book Your Boss Doesn't Want You To Read

UNDERLINGS: The Book Your Boss Doesn’t Want You To Read

“The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars,
But in ourselves, that we are underlings.”
–Julius Caesar, I.ii


What follows is a corporate response to the question: Why did the chicken cross the road?

“Deregulation of the chicken's side of the road was threatening its dominant market position. The chicken was faced with significant challenges to create and develop the competencies required for the newly competitive market. Andersen Consulting, in a partnering relationship with the client, helped the chicken by rethinking its physical distribution strategy and implementation processes. Using the Poultry Integration Model (PIM), Andersen helped the chicken use its skills, methodologies, knowledge, capital and experiences to align the chicken's people, processes and technology in support of its overall strategy within a Program Management framework. Andersen Consulting convened a diverse cross-spectrum of road analysts and best chickens along with Anderson consultants with deep skills in the transportation industry to engage in a two-day itinerary of meetings in order to leverage their personal knowledge capital, both tacit and explicit, and to enable them to synergize with each other in order to achieve the implicit goals of delivering and successfully architecting and implementing an enterprise-wide value framework across the continuum of poultry cross-median processes.

“The meeting was held in a park-like setting, enabling and creating an impactful environment which was strategically based, industry-focused, and built upon a consistent, clear, and unified market message and aligned with the chicken's mission, vision, and core values. This was conducive towards the creation of a total business integration solution. Andersen Consulting helped the chicken change to become more successful…”

The above, from Wikipedia, would be hilarious were it not so close to reality. As it is, ‘tragic’ is a better characterization, because people are getting hurt every day, partly as a result of such dribble. Is it any wonder then, after reading the ‘chicken’ parable, that vulnerable human beings get lost, set-adrift, in the corporate profit calculation?

The truth is that the approach employed by the fictional consultants to move poultry from point A to point B, is the same as the corporate approach to managing human beings.

Underlings might be described as the ‘other side’ of the brilliantly conceived book, Outliers (Little, Brown, & Co. 2008), by Malcolm Gladwell. In Outliers, Gladwell dissects those components necessary, and almost always present, when someone of exceptional ability rises above the rest in station, income, revealed talent, and access to other ‘outliers.’ Specifically, he describes a culture in which the game is rigged in favor of a very few exceptional people, and as a result, he says, many exceptional people never get a fair shot; their potential contributions are never fully realized.

The ‘Outlier’ has his cross to bear, no doubt. Bill Gates, the Microsoft billionaire, had ready access to computers when he was in high school, at a time (1968) when most colleges did not have a computer lab, and few adolescents had any awareness of computers at all. Gladwell describes Gate’s fortunate circumstances---“His [Gate’s] father was a wealthy lawyer in Seattle, and his mother the daughter of a well-to-do banker…[they] sent him to Lakeside, a private school that catered to Seattle’s elite families.” (pp. 50-55, Outliers)

Certainly others, even if only a small number of ‘outliers,’ possessed Gate’s aptitude, but few enjoyed his financially secure family and access to the best tools and training imaginable for success in the computer world.

In Outliers, Gladwell is persuasive when he argues, cryptically, “people don’t rise from nothing.” He assures us that indeed, upon closer examination, “we owe something to parentage and patronage…the people who stand before Kings may look like they did it all by themselves…but in fact they are invariably beneficiaries of hidden advantages and extraordinary opportunities…” (p.19, Outliers)

Underlings on the other hand, is a story of the great mass of us who endure subsistence wages, lack of access to education and health care, and a frighteningly insecure old-age.

Where the relatively rare breed of ‘outlier’ whom Gladwell chronicles are passionate about their work, and are demonstrably extraordinary in some way; ‘Underlings’ blend into the crowd by virtue of their extraordinary numbers. Hardly passionate about their work, Underlings toil day after day, year after year; at below poverty wages, unable to escape the emotional weight of circumstances, which offer little prospect of improving in the future, and indeed seem only to get worse.

Reconstructing Pinchback

The Post-Reconstruction Career of Pinckney Benton Stewart Pinchback


Elizabeth Lilly Stewart

“P. B. S. Pinchback is a crucial, but neglected figure of the Reconstruction era and, indeed, of 19th-century African American history. This book is the first serious study of Pinchback and as such will make its mark on the field and will be welcomed by anyone who wants to know more about a pivotal moment in the American past.”

Eric Foner, DeWitt Clinton Professor of History, Columbia University; author of Forever Free: The Story of Emancipation and Reconstruction.

Copyright ©1979 Elizabeth L. Stewart

(2002 Norman G. Stewart)

All Rights Reserved

Introduction and personal note about the author

Elizabeth Lilly Stewart was a graduate student when Dr. Joe Gray Taylor, Chairman of the History Department at McNeese State University, asked her to write a review for a scholarly journal of a prominent Historian’s newest offering. The book she was to review, and criticize if necessary, was the first and only biography ever written of Pinckney Benton Stewart Pinchback, Reconstruction governor of Louisiana, and the first African American to be governor of a State. As the book was authored by James Haskins, an established scholar, she worried being viewed as immodest, or even an ‘upstart’ should she reveal flaws in the work. I know that because I was there; she was my mother.

Why would Dr Taylor, the Historian who was, at that time, arguably America’s leading expert on Reconstruction in Louisiana, ask a graduate student to undertake such a task? The answer is that my mother had chosen to write her Master’s thesis on P.B.S. Pinchback, and was in the midst of years of primary research on the subject. She was, in effect, the best-qualified person to write such a review.

My mother’s later reference to James Haskins’ biography in her own book on Pinchback reveals in part the results of the review she penned for the Louisiana History Journal. She recorded her view of Mr. Haskins’ book with generosity, though not entirely to his advantage:

“James Haskins’ skillfully blended fact and supposition (emphasis mine) to produce the first and only biography of P.B.S. Pinchback, making knowledge of the notable black leader more accessible to the general public.”

Elizabeth Stewart taught school, cared for her husband and children, and chiseled away at her lifelong dream, a Master’s degree in History, which she attained, nearly concomitantly with a Master's in Library Science, cum laude. Dr. Taylor was her thesis advisor, and was near completion of his award winning work on Reconstruction in Louisiana. She was passionate about the study and practice of history, and was elated to be present for her mentor’s greatest achievement. I proudly display in my home the copy of Louisiana Reconstructed he endorsed for her. It was among her most cherished possessions.

Though too fine a scholar to relegate the practice of history to ax-grinding, she was keenly aware of the controversy surrounding Pinchback, most of it associated with the corruption and chicanery well known to that period in the South, especially in Louisiana.

“That he joined the other politicians of his day in using his position for personal financial gain is a matter of record. Pinchback’s participation in the Mississippi Riverboat Packet Company and the land deal he made while Park Commissioner resulted in profit for him while costing the state many thousands of dollars... [and] made up a small portion of the web of corruption, bribery, and unethical practices for which the Republicans were blamed during Reconstruction in Louisiana.”

Were we to dismiss past players for such failings and character defects, we would have to remove from the record their sacrifices and accomplishments as well, which would be shortsighted concerning a species that has always trudged along with “feet of clay.” To examine notable people in ‘parts;’ to attempt to separate the greatness from the character defect, is to create a science experiment, and not to practice history. In any event, we have only what was recorded at the time by the participants with which to navigate the past. And though there is much we may surmise from the available evidence, we must ultimately turn to the record in light of the unarguable proposition that “they were there, and we were not.”

History must have the final word, as the great French Historian Marc Bloch wrote in his unfinished work, The Historian’s Craft, “For History is the most authoritative of dictators.” Monsieur Bloch knew something about dictators, as he wrote the previous sentence while a prisoner of the Nazis, just before being murdered by them.

So it is that Mrs. Stewart neither apologizes nor does she excuse, but rather she finds data of sufficient historical efficacy to explain and understand Pinchback; a task no one had up to that time, (and not since then), even attempted. She firmly believed that men should be considered in the context of their own time, and was to say often “I am a pastist.”

The trail my mother followed those many years pouring over the papers of six presidents, the unpublished papers of Jean Toomer (Pinchback’s famous grandson and the author of Cane), and hundreds of related documents, revealed a remarkable Black political leader at a time when the very idea of ‘black political leader’ was an untried and unwelcome anomaly in America, and an ominous endeavor, even for a relatively light skinned ‘Negro’ such as Pinchback. And though in a rare historical moment “conditions were favorable,” (the period from 1870 to 1877 was dubbed the “Era of Black Power in Dixie”), she records for posterity the difficulty, the danger, and the uncertainty of Pinchback’s fortunes.

Pinchback himself could not have felt secure, and never ceased building a bulwark, or sanctuary for his mother “who had known slavery,” his wife of sixty-one years, and his beloved children and grandchildren.

“Pinchback needed more than his identification as a quadroon to become an outstanding black Reconstructionist,” Mrs. Stewart writes in her introduction. Then, with the precision of a research historian and the experience of a Southern woman raised in the Jim Crow South who rejected the bigotry of her birthplace, she demonstrates Pinchback’s struggle to do as well as the white people, and if not as well, then merely to survive in an increasingly dangerous Dixie.

Pinchback was not unique among black men in that his fortunes, at times considerable, “were inextricably tied to those of his race.” He prospered during Reconstruction, but was essentially broke by the time of his death in 1921.

Frederick Douglas, Pinchback's friend and mutual admirer, died in 1895, leaving W.E.B. DuBois the black leader of favor. Pinchback was thought by the turn of the century too close to the Booker T. Washington-led “accomodationists,” and thus, for most of the twentieth century, on the ‘wrong side’ of history.

There is no record or indication that Pinchback had ever read Harriet Beecher Stowe's book that would coin the term used by later generations to disparage him and the Tuskegans with the label “Uncle Tom.” Mrs. Stewart assures us that the historical record indicates no such thing. The breath and complexity of such men as Washington and Pinchback cannot be captured in a single term whether or not the intention is to praise or disparage.

And while a more enlightened view has emerged since the time of the present work, the ‘new’ view, at least regarding Pinchback, is based more upon realization of tragedy perpetrated upon black men of Pinchback’s time, and less upon a thorough study of the elusive ex-governor. Mrs. Stewart’s book on Pinchback provides a learned Historian’s look at the scattered and fading record, and confirms what intuition and modern rejection of persistent prejudice seems to have concluded: That Pinchback and other determined, self-made black men and women stood up to be counted before conditions were safe to do so, is an historical axiom. And that he and others persisted in the face of life-killing affronts when relegation to second-class citizenship was the law of the land, is a matter of record.

Contemporary observers cannot quite seem to wrap their arms around this most ambitious and energetic man. Pinchback is mentioned in nearly all books on Reconstruction written since World War II, but as though hoping not to be asked for details, Historians have so far, with the exception of the present work, neglected to go beyond their minimal obligation to mention the fact of his existence. And who could blame them? Information about Pinchback beyond government documents was, and remains difficult to obtain. As late as 1974, over fifty years after his death, Pinchback was still missing from the roster of governors in my eighth grade Louisiana History textbook.

Historical scholarship since the nineteen seventies has indeed improved the lens through which we are able to view the Tuskeegans led by Booker T. Washington---they now appear essential, and part and parcel of a singular desire for the full rights of citizenship for Black Americans. Less attention is focused now upon who was ‘right,’ or who best advanced the cause of political and civil rights, than seemed important in the years immediately following the murder of Martin Luther King, and more paid to the skill, the sacrifices, and accomplishments of the men and women who held the line so that later leaders could once again move the cause forward.

The post Reconstruction South gave birth to an historical paradigm emboldened by the zeitgeist of a region determined to dispel any notions that they had fought against, or had been forced to accept, full-citizenship for blacks. The war they lost in 1865 was, they contended (and I often heard my grandmother assert), a “War of Northern Aggression,” no more, and no less. “States Rights was the issue,” or so the Revisionists would assert, and not in fact the South’s desire to defend chattel slavery, nor the North’s desire, albeit latent, to see slavery eradicated from the land where all men were declared, nearly a hundred years prior, to be created equal.

Revisionist Historians, in the pejorative use of the phrase, attempted to shine a warm, nostalgic light upon the ante-bellum South, and for a time succeeded in setting forth arguments for the “axiom” that black citizens could not be trusted with political power, and held up men such as Pinchback as proof of their claim.

However, the Jim Crow laws that swept like a brush fire across the South in the early part of the twentieth century, as well as attempts to frame the civil war instigated by their secession from, and dismemberment of the Union as a “just” war for the rights of free citizens, belied their arguments that the fight was for state’s rights. Poor whites in the South feared a free Negro population; wealthy whites feared the loss of their fortunes, and thus their way of life premised upon the enslavement of an entire class of Americans.

Pinchback and his colleagues, in their fight for full citizenship were, in the fervor to alter the record, either lost to history, and if not ‘lost,’ then maligned as “corrupt,” and even “dangerous.”

Mrs. Stewart’s mission was not to construct a ‘revision’ of the history of Pinchback and his times, but rather a reversion to the record. Her upbringing by a mother and grandmothers who were born and reared in the post-Reconstruction South caused her to observe that “Left to the women of the South, (and perhaps contradicting various feminist revisionist histories), slavery would have continued unabated.”

In the 1970’s the work of Joe Gray Taylor and James Haskins, and since then the rising tide of scholarship on Reconstruction, in the vanguard of which are Historians such as Eric Foner, Hans Trefousse, and Ted Tunnell, has lifted Pinchback as well.

Pinchback’s revival began with Haskins’ biography in 1973, which was followed by a project to have a bust of the ex-governor placed among his fellow governors in Huey P. Long’s beloved State House. Pinchback wrote and then fought for the text at the 1879 Louisiana Constitutional Convention, which provided for the creation of Southern University, where he is “held in high esteem,” and where a new engineering complex bears his name.

Although attitudes toward the “accomodationists” have changed in favor of previously suspect Black leaders, the present volume remains the only comprehensive scholarship on P.B.S. Pinchback.

Mrs. Stewart was a participant in generating the “flurry of scholarship in the 1970’s” on Reconstruction to which Professor Foner refers in his landmark book, Forever Free: The Story of Emancipation and Reconstruction. In the light of her own mentor, Joe Gray Taylor’s, and the work of other historians already extant, she did not attempt a volume on Reconstruction per se, but rather the story, as far as can be known, of one of that period’s most remarkable leaders.

In the introduction to Reconstructing Pinchback, Mrs. Stewart begins setting up her explanation of Pinchback’s extraordinary life and times:

“The meteoric rise of Pinchback to key positions in Louisiana government in the years from 1867 to 1877,” she writes, “caused observers...to characterize him as a brilliant politician, self-seeking, useful, dangerous, corrupt, upright, and shrewd.” Hegelian reductionism would not do. She wanted first and foremost to understand, and as such her pristine, elegantly crisp prose lacks the ornamentation and editorializing (‘supposition’?) common to hitherto self-indulgent efforts regarding this complicated and controversial man.

She hoped to find simpler terms by which to convey the enormous complexities of post-bellum Louisiana for the purpose of illuminating the life of one man within the confines of the available evidence---a “witches cauldron”---and she agreed with Einstein who said that he hoped to find simpler terms for difficult and meandering constructs, “But not too simple.” I was present to hear my mother call her search for historical material on Pinchback a “search for a needle in a burning haystack.”

Agnes Smith Grosz, in the 1940’s, wrote an admirable and scholarly account of Pinchback’s political career, but the narrative tapers off in the year 1877, leaving the record of Pinchback’s remaining forty-four years essentially unexamined by lay and historian alike. “Confounding future generations,” Mrs. Stewart wrote, (and no doubt warning away historians), “is the fact that Pinchback’s personal papers were burned soon after his death,” an act which she always considered nefarious, the truth of which she was unable to prove.

But my mother was not deterred, and after over ten years dedicated to meticulous research, she composed the present volume, which provides the truth of the man, and the rest of the story of P.B.S. Pinchback’s remarkable and productive life.

Note about the text, and a personal note:

No one knew anything about personal computers in the 1970’s, and so my mother typed her paper on a small, portable typewriter given to her in 1942. For that reason I have done some formatting that she was unable to do on her beloved ‘Smith-Corona,’ and on occasion have rephrased in order to liven up what was intended to dwell only in the archives of academia, accessible to scholars, but not to a wider audience of interested book consumers.

She was satisfied to have accomplished the task of uncovering the truth about Pinchback and leave it at that. But I was not satisfied to have her work lost to posterity. I chose to guide this work to publication myself rather than hand it over to experts for the simple, admittedly emotional reason that I thought myself best qualified to protect her legacy. To that end, I have left the text alone, with one or two insignificant exceptions. I undertake the publication of her work by way of no expressed wish or permission on my mother’s part. However, if for a moment I thought she would not approve, I too would ‘leave it at that.’

Both P.B.S. Pinchback and generations of students were deprived so long as my mother’s work remained in a box, inadvertently hidden from history, and representing a substantial gap in the record. She reflected Pinchback’s unwillingness to record his own accomplishments, and like the subject of her work, was instead busy every day working to manifest results, attending to her next challenge, or whatever was new and interesting and life enhancing. She was privately proud to be a member of a small group of female Historians of her generation, the most notable of which was Pulitzer winner Barbara Tuchman, whom she considered one of the great historians, and who was, I can attest, her idol.

She had three primary dreams that I am aware of. First and foremost she wanted to see her six children grow to be “happy, contributing adults.” Second, she wanted to be an Historian; and third, she wanted someday to retire and open a used bookstore.

Though my mother was to see three of her children die before her own death in 2002, she did indeed become an Historian, and she later retired to a small island off the coast of Washington State and opened, with a good friend, a used bookstore. She never wanted to sell anything, and was often caught, to the bewilderment of her business partners, placing a carefully selected book in the hand of a child while refusing the child’s parents’ attempt to pay for it.

And so it is with great pride and deep affection that I am pleased, along with my sister Margaret, my brother David, and my father, Norman Stewart, (ever my mother’s champion), to offer Elizabeth Lilly Stewart’s accurate, incisive, and poignant account of the man who earned the distinction of holding more political offices than any other African American in history.

Glenn Stewart, San Juan Island, Washington, 2006

Tuesday, January 25, 2011

Prologue, "Becoming Townsend"

“There are no conditions to which a man cannot get accustomed, especially if he sees them accepted by everyone around him”---Tolstoy



Prologue

Savannah

December, 1864

She stood on the porch and looked to the west where the Sun was nearly on the horizon. The brilliant orange and yellow sky she had known from the time she was a girl was set not to an orchestra hired for the magnificent parties she remembered, but to the ominous rumble of cannon being brought to crush her world by her family’s enemies.

Her husband, George Harrison Jr., was in a prison up North somewhere, captured by the Yankees nine months ago. She had sent away the slaves since it was rumored that the Yankees were easier on those who had set the Negroes free. Only she, her ten children, and three loyal house slaves who refused to leave, remained.

The house slaves had buried the large pieces of silver in the floor of the henhouse to keep them from Yankee looters. That silver service and the matching flatware were all that was left of a once grand estate that had required the love and labor of five generations to build.

Word had already reached them of the devastation wrought by Sherman’s army. Lincoln’s most horrific General, the father of “total warfare,” had cut a swath of destruction through Georgia, and determined to conquer all that lay between a smoldering Atlanta and the Atlantic Ocean. Her own plantation was directly in the path of the Yankees, and they would soon be here.

When the Union army officers approached, Maggie waited, stoically, bravely to confront them. She had heard tales of pillage, brutality, of rape and murder. There was nowhere to go, no one to protect her children, for the men had all long since gone to fight for the lost cause.

Anger welled up inside of her, but it was strangely not directed at the men who approached in their blue uniforms. She thought only of how senseless it all was, of the men who so foolishly provoked the North to fight this bloody, horrible war. She was angry at her husband, no doubt suffering terribly in a Yankee prison camp, for leaving her here with their children; she was angry that the men, her men, had started this war with the North even though there was no hope of defeating the Yankees and their endless supply of men and steel and ammunition. She would gladly have given up her beautiful house, her slaves, and the gentle life she had always known, to prevent all of this; to prevent this inevitable moment. She was angry all right, and she was scared.

The officers stopped a hundred feet from the cavernous porch that was supported by towering Greek pillars. The house her husband’s great, great grandfather had built over a hundred years ago stood like the Parthenon, dwarfing the men who dared to approach and take it from her.

One officer rode away from the rest toward the porch and stopped just a few yards from where she stood. She thought she should step down, but her position above the officer, though symbolic, was all she had left with which to confront him. He would have to come up those stairs to get her. She was not going to make it easy for him, she would not callow; she would keep her head above his head.

He climbed down off his horse and approached, stopping when he reached the base of the wide, sweeping stairs. He removed his hat and placed it under his arm. His head bent down, and then he looked up at her.

“Ma’am, I’m Colonel Wilson, of General Wheeler’s Cavalry.” She stared at him for what seemed like a long time. He was not the ugly monster she had heard about from those already burned out and looted by the Yankees. He was courteous, his voice gentle. She had prepared herself to confront him in anger. Her own voice was prepared to yell, “No!” But that would not do, not with what she was seeing now.

“Suh, I am Maggie Harrison. What is your business here?” She surprised herself when the words came out. She knew exactly why he was there. Not far behind him was the entire Yankee army ready to burn and pillage. They were here to conquer.

“We mean you no harm Ma’am. Are there any men here?” He didn’t seem concerned that there were men here. He already knew as she did that the men were gone, and most of them were dead. No Southern man would have left the women standing on the porch if they had been there, and she knew that the Yankee officer knew that as well.

“Only my children and I remain here. Do what you need to do and please be on your way.”

“We’ll need the valuables Ma’am, but you’ll not be harmed. If you’ll bring us what you have there will be no need to enter the house.” Maggie thought of the empty house, everything sold to feed the children, and wondered what she could give them to satisfy their lust for spoils. She thought of the big silver pieces hidden in the floor of the henhouse, including George’s coveted silver pitcher, an heirloom bequeathed to the Harrisons by James Oglethorpe, founder of the Georgia colony. And she thought of the silverware still in the cupboard.

Maggie turned without a word and went inside. She removed a flour sack from the pantry and filled it with the silver flatware. The children remained upstairs, out of sight as she had told them to do. She carried the heavy sack of bounty to the porch where the officer patiently waited.

“The youngest is taking medicine, may I have a teaspoon?” She looked straight at the officer when she said it, her face void of expression, with no visible emotion, she made the simple request. Her dignity and lack of theatrics had impressed the Colonel, and so he reached into the flour sack and retrieved a small, curled handled spoon. For the first time he stepped onto the stairs that lead to where she stood. With his head slightly down, as though he were approaching a Queen, he handed the spoon to Maggie. He then backed down the stairs, mounted his horse, and rode away, turning only to tip his hat, as though in tribute to her bravery and remarkable decorum.

Townsend had not been burned, and she and her children had not been harmed. When they rode away, Maggie Harrison took her first full breath since the invaders appeared at her home…


Part One

London

April 1733

“I have to get on that ship!” pleaded George to the guards. Saying it aloud was answered by a cat ‘o nine-tails to the back, a particularly painful form of whip, really nine short whips tied together in an ingeniously efficient manner so as to allow the guards to inflict excruciating, stinging pain with the snap of their wrists. It was maddening---and would drive him mad if he did not get to the Anne. He had planned and saved, and borrowed. Maybe he pushed the limits of the law just a bit, but no one was hurt, and he needed the money for the trip to America, from whence he would not bother them again.

“You’ll get on a ship alright, scum!---A ship to Australia, the most god-forsaken place known to human kind it-is.” George was numb to the harsh Cockney’s and their cruelty, all but the whip that is, of that he still felt the full measure. He tried to turn his body so that the leather wouldn’t slash open the wounds still seething, red and burning.

The only indication that it was daytime was the small amount of light that

peeked through the rotting planks of the deck above. Day was only slightly better than night---better because the rats were only active at night when they foraged for food in the black darkness of the deep hold of the prison ship. They were voracious, constantly in motion, searching for anything that resembled food, including the extremities of the barely alive men and women chained to the giant ribs of the ship. The wood through which the iron spikes that held their chains secure was the only part of the ship not moist and soggy and teaming with wood eating worms, the only part tended to by the carpenters so that the pitiful souls imprisoned there could not escape.

BT

“My Dear, is he right?” Sarah pushed the London Gazette toward George, offered him a view of what she was reading. He didn’t look up; he remained silent, hoping he could just continue without answering. They did this all the time. Sarah had grown used to having to ask at least twice. “He says we can’t do it without forced labor….is he right?” George leaned over the maps he had been studying for months. She waited for his finger to finish tracing a line, allowed him to finish the journey that existed so far only in his thoughts. He was deep in thought, he always seemed that way.

George Harrison didn’t live out here in the space we all share, he lived in his own inner world. His speech was sparse, efficient, nothing added, almost no emotion, just enough words to settle the necessity of the moment. Some thought him an ascetic of sorts, but they were wrong. He lived in reality more than most, he just did not like small talk.

Though he was a compact man, average in height and size, the opposite of imposing, men looked up to him. Sarah had never heard anyone say one bad word about her husband. Annoyance and exasperation were the only emotions anyone but Sarah ever saw him express. There was the rare expression of anger, but it took a lot to get a rise out of him.

“What do you mean? Who says---?”

“Thurlowe, that man from Oxford. He’s studied it for years, says here the Oglethorpe mission is a boondoggle, a waste of the taxpayers’ money.”

“Well then, he’s an idiot, and wrong on both counts. It can be done, and the money is all private,” replied George, clearly growing annoyed. “Besides, when did he ever venture beyond the Ivy of Oxford?” Sarah pushed the tabloid closer to George.

“You should read what he has to say.” George exhaled enough to appear bothered, always a signal that he had accepted the inevitable, and took the paper from his wife. He leaned back in his chair and began reading. The article was entitled “Englishman or Slaver?”

He had seen it before. The Reformists long ago divided into two camps---those who wanted to change the way land was settled in the New World, and those who wanted to stop colonization altogether.

The latter group thought the tendency to exploit could not be overcome, that the best intentions would give way to expediency as they had always done. There was plenty of poverty, desperation and injustice right here in England, and spreading that around the world was immoral, they thought.

“Slaves perished at Jamestown along with the rest,” the article began, “and have been present in the New World since the Spanish first set foot there.”

It was an age-old argument, human nature versus human progress. George was for progress. He read on, only because Sarah wanted him to. “Climate, topography, the long hot summers, long growing seasons, and rich soil make large agriculture inevitable. Take into account the many rivers for getting the crops to distant ports, and the stage is set for the Plantation system the Virginians have predictably constructed. Large landholdings create a demand for a large, chattel labor force.”

George looked up at Sarah. She was both soft and strong at once. Her sophistication and gracious manner transcended caste, religion and family origin. Her movement was the same whether among the most wretched poor, or the top drawer of London society. She was proper without a hint of superiority. Everyone felt at ease in her presence. Men especially desired her, in the confines of their thoughts only, as the times required unwavering discretion. She in turn never lead any of them to believe they could win her affection. George did not try to impress her, he did not prance, which in her mind set him apart from all of the others.

“There were plantations in the New World before there were slaves working them, my dear wife…we can tame the wilderness of Georgia just as well with small farms as with large ones. Who is this Thurlowe to say we can’t?”

He was measured in his counter argument, his disdain for Thurlowe’s words had not yet turned to anger. They had an implicit arrangement. Sarah would not push, and in turn, George would not overreact. Most of the time they honored their arrangement.

George didn’t mind so much that others were wrong, most inevitably got it wrong. He was imminently rational, if mildly misanthropic. What really bothered him was anyone else trying to tell him what he can, and cannot do.

“He says English resources should remain in England. Does he not have a point?” Sarah gently posed the question. Devil’s advocate was a role only she could play, so long as she was careful.

One could see the wheels in his mind spinning. Under the cool, pensive exterior was the energy of five men combined. Sarah’s beloved Shakespeare described her husband perfectly---“A peace above all earthly dignities, a still and quiet conscience.” At least that described George when he was not angered. When he got riled; when the pretense and arrogance of the upper caste men offended him, Shakespeare firmly placed the words on George’s lips---“Vain pomp and glory of this world, I hate ye.”

Brian Thurlowe had served in Parliament with Oglethorpe, and for many years they shared a reformist dream. But Oglethorpe was no longer content, after over thirty years trying, to debate the Conservatives. Words had gotten them no where. None of the reforms they proposed had ever become law.

Modern Feudalism, though under the guise now of the newly popular Capitalism, had been gaining steam for a century, and had easily run down every other proposal for organizing society upon more just principles.

Oglethorpe wanted action, and when he proposed a utopian colony to be named for the King, he and Thurlowe split. No longer content to drink brandy and engage in academic debates in the elegant drawing rooms of London, Oglethorpe began to denounce all of Parliament as a stodgy, unproductive “gaggle”---he stopped short of using the word ‘corrupt.’

“The House of Commons is wholly controlled by ancient, landed and manufacturing interests. And the Lords?”---The trademark Oglethorpe smile grew as he circled his prey---“Well, the problem with them is obvious.” His populist message was not lost on the King, who reserved the prerogative of appealing to the popular will for himself, and did not like being upstaged by any Subject, even an Oglethorpe. The General toyed with treason, and in that potentially self-injurious act, gained the trust of the lower classes he was trying to help.

“This Thurlowe is a writer, more a writer than a thinker,” said George without looking up from the tabloid, “he’s crafty with the language, always holds the reader’s attention.” Indeed, George was immediately drawn into the account, sensational in the extreme, of the cruel treatment of slaves in Maryland. He continued reading the long article, which covered three columns in the smallest print imaginable.

“The poor, frightened Negro dared glance at a white woman, and suffered the consequences imposed by her husband. The Negro was right off the ship, having been captured like an animal and sent to America in the dreaded, airless, rancid hold of a cargo vessel. Sick and hungry, barely able to stand, the confused and frightened man was dragged away to the nearest Elm tree, where a rope was thrown over a large branch, and formed into a noose around his neck. The whites, some as poor and undernourished as the slave, watched and cheered, shook their fists in the air, all determined to teach the other Negroes the rules for living amongst superior beings…” George looked up at Sarah.

“I’ve read enough, I get his point my Dear.”

“George, that place is where you propose to go, how are we to survive in such a place? That barbarity has been going on there for two hundred years, and you and Oglethorpe propose to change it?”

“No Sarah, I propose that we go to a place where such things do not exist, we are going to a wilderness to begin our colony anew, and to live by our own rules.”

“My darling, you must read the whole article, if you do, you will understand what is happening there.” Sarah knew that George was well familiar with the reformists’ views, but she would not accept her husband’s dismissal of the account. “They just stood by and watched those men torture those Negroes. It is, my Dear, the most sadistic, primitive instinct at work, and that with the blessing of our King…they hanged pregnant women!---An ocean hardly provides enough distance from those animals, and you wish to be their neighbors?!” George remained calm in the face of Sarah’s pleading. He had a plan, and he would not be deterred.

“Dear Sarah, because Massachusetts and Maryland do such things does not mean we shall perpetrate the same crimes in Georgia.” He looked directly at her for the first time since he began reading, “Oglethorpe will not have it, and nor will I.” Sarah heard her husband’s words, but in her mind she could see only grinning white mobs torturing helpless captives. It was no use to try and dissuade George Harrison. They were going to America, slaves or no slaves.